Heroine Make Advanced Film vs Super Waterproof: Which mascara should you buy?
What should you choose?
Choose Advanced Film if easier removal matters most. Choose Super Waterproof if you want the range built around stronger resistance to water, sweat and rubbing, and you’re happy to use makeup remover. Both families offer curl focused formulas. Advanced Film needs warm water and facial cleanser, not water alone.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
For length and easier removal
Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Advanced Film
Choose Long & Curl Advanced Film when you want a lengthening mascara that fits a warm water and face wash routine. It resists water and sebum during wear, then loosens with warm water before cleansing.
For length and durable wear
Heroine Make Long UP Mascara Super WP N
Choose Long UP Super WP N when resistance to water, sweat and rubbing is your priority. Its curved brush is designed to separate lashes. Plan to remove it with an oil based cleanser or mascara remover.
For taking off waterproof mascara
Heroine Make Speedy Mascara Remover
Speedy Mascara Remover has a comb applicator that spreads remover along your lashes. It’s a useful addition if your usual cleanser struggles with waterproof mascara, rather than a step everyone needs.
The difference that matters at the sink
| Your priority | Start here | Removal |
|---|---|---|
| Length with a simpler removal routine | Long & Curl Advanced Film | Warm water, then facial cleanser |
| Durable wear through water and sweat | Long UP Super WP N | Makeup remover or oil based cleanser |
| A fuller lash look | A Volume formula in your chosen family | Follow that formula’s instructions |
Decide how you want to remove your mascara before choosing the brush. Buying a waterproof formula when you dislike a separate removal step is an easy way to end up with a product you rarely reach for.
Is Advanced Film a tubing mascara?
Heroine Make describes Advanced Film as combining features of film and waterproof formulas. Calling it simply a tubing mascara can hide the important part: the brand tells you to use cleanser after warm water.
That makes it a practical choice if you want water and sebum resistance during an ordinary day but prefer removing your mascara while washing your face. It doesn’t establish that every person will get the same curl hold or experience no smudging.
Long and Volume are a separate choice
The family name tells you about wear and removal. The Long or Volume name tells you about the intended finish.
The Long Advanced Film formula emphasizes length. Volume Advanced Film uses shorter fibers and a brush designed to deliver a fuller coat. In the Super Waterproof family, Long UP and Volume UP also have different brushes. Pick the finish you actually want rather than assuming the longest product name is the strongest version.
The current US waterproof lineup includes Long UP Super WP N. Older Long & Curl and Long UP products still appear online. This comparison’s waterproof recommendation is the N formula pictured above.
How to remove each one
For Advanced Film, wet the lashes with warm water first, then use facial cleanser as directed. If mascara remains, use makeup remover instead of repeatedly pulling at your lashes.
For Super Waterproof, use a suitable oil based cleanser or the dedicated remover. With Speedy Mascara Remover, brush it through from roots to tips, then follow the brand’s wiping or cleansing directions. A dedicated remover is convenient, but you don’t need to buy one if your existing remover already works comfortably.
If you’re choosing beyond this brand, see our Japanese mascara guide. For the rest of the range, use the Heroine Make guide.
Common questions
Does Heroine Make Advanced Film come off with water alone?
The official instructions say to loosen it with warm water and then use facial cleanser. Water alone is not the complete removal method.
Do I need Speedy Mascara Remover for Super Waterproof?
No. Heroine Make also recommends an oil based cleanser. The dedicated remover is useful if your usual removal routine struggles with the mascara.
Should I choose Long or Volume?
Choose Long for a length focused finish and Volume for a fuller lash look. Choose Advanced Film or Super Waterproof separately, based on wear and removal preferences.
Sources
We compared published product information. This guide does not describe personal testing. Sources checked October 5, 2026.