Best Japanese Mascara: Waterproof, Lengthening, and Film Formulas
Quick Takeaway
- Best overall: Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Advanced Film removes with warm water, holds curl all day, and works on even the shortest, straightest lashes.
- Best waterproof: Heroine Make Volume & Curl Mascara and Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Super WP are borderline indestructible but require an oil cleanser or the Heroine Make Speedy Mascara Remover to take off.
- Best budget pick: Canmake Metalook Mascara has a thin metal wand that separates every lash, costs under $15, and regularly tops @cosme rankings.
- Cult favorite: Dejavu Fiberwig Mascara pioneered warm water removal and still has a loyal following, though availability outside Japan can be limited.
- The key difference: Japanese mascaras split into two camps: traditional waterproof (oil removal required) and film/tube type (warm water removal). Understanding this is the single most useful thing you can learn before buying.
Japanese mascaras solve a problem that Western formulas mostly ignore: straight, downward pointing lashes. In Japan, holding a curl is the primary performance metric for mascara. Everything else (volume, length, smudge resistance) comes second. That priority shapes the entire product category, from the polymer film coatings to the ultra thin wands.
The result is a lineup of mascaras that work exceptionally well for people with sparse, short, or stubbornly straight lashes. But they also work for anyone who’s tired of the raccoon eye look by 3 PM.
This guide covers the best picks across both formula types, explains what makes each one different, and helps you figure out which one fits your lash situation.
Why Japanese Mascara Is Different: Film vs Waterproof
Most Japanese mascaras fall into one of two categories, and the distinction matters more than any other feature on the label.
Waterproof (traditional)
Waterproof Japanese mascaras use wax and silicone based formulas that physically resist water, sweat, and oil. They hold curl extremely well because the rigid film locks lashes in place. KissMe’s Heroine Make line is the most famous example.
The tradeoff: they require an oil based cleanser or a dedicated mascara remover to take off. Regular face wash won’t cut it. Multiple Reddit users report that even micellar water and cleansing balms struggle with Heroine Make’s waterproof formulas. The brand sells its own Heroine Make Speedy Mascara Remover for this reason, and experienced users consider it essential.
Film type (warm water removal)
Film mascaras (sometimes called tube mascaras) coat each lash in a water soluble polymer tube. During the day, this tube is resistant to sweat and oil, so it won’t smudge. But at the end of the day, warm water (around 38 to 40°C) dissolves the polymer and the tubes slide off your lashes in small pieces.
Dejavu Fiberwig Mascara helped popularize this technology in the early 2000s, and most Japanese brands now offer at least one film formula. Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Advanced Film combines the curl holding power of the waterproof line with warm water removal, which is why it has become the single most recommended Japanese mascara online.
Why this matters for you
If you want maximum hold and don’t mind a two step removal process, go waterproof. If you want easy removal without sacrificing smudge resistance during the day, go film type.
Many people keep one of each. Waterproof for long days, outdoor events, and humidity. Film type for everyday wear and gentler removal.
Best Film Type Mascara: Heroine Make Long and Curl Advanced Film
Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Advanced Film
This is the mascara that dominates every “best Japanese mascara” list, and the reputation is earned. It combines a curl locking polymer with warm water removability, which is the combination most people want.
What it does well:
- Holds curl on straight, downward pointing lashes for 8 to 10+ hours
- Lengthens without clumping
- Removes cleanly with warm water (no oil cleanser needed)
- Doesn’t flake or smudge during the day
The wand is slim with short bristles, which gives you precision but requires building up coats for volume. This is a lengthening mascara, not a volumizing one. If you want both, layer it over a primer or pair it with the Volume and Curl version on outer lashes.
A popular thread on r/AsianBeauty compared this directly against Dejavu Fiberwig Mascara, with the original poster choosing Heroine Make after finding that Dejavu couldn’t hold a curl. The comments were full of similar experiences: Heroine Make’s curl hold is in a class of its own.
KissMe
3 retailersSee retailers →
KissMe also makes a micro wand version (Heroine Make Mini Mascara) that’s even thinner, designed for reaching inner corner lashes and lower lashes. Same film formula, just a smaller brush.
Best Waterproof Mascaras: Heroine Make’s Super WP Line
If warm water removal isn’t important to you and you want the most bulletproof hold possible, Heroine Make’s waterproof line is where to look.
Heroine Make Volume and Curl Mascara
Heroine Make Volume & Curl Mascara
The volume focused option. This gives thicker, more dramatic lashes compared to the film version. The formula is dense and builds up quickly, so one to two coats is usually enough.
It is genuinely difficult to remove. Reddit users regularly describe needing the brand’s dedicated remover or a heavy oil cleanser. One commenter described having “a full blown sobbing meltdown” while wearing it and the mascara “didn’t even budge an inch.” That’s the level of hold you’re dealing with.
Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara Super WP
Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Super WP
The lengthening focused waterproof option. Same extreme hold as the Volume and Curl, but with a formula optimized for extension rather than thickness. Good for people who want defined, separated lashes rather than a fuller look.
Heroine Make Prime Volume Up Mascara Super Waterproof
Heroine Make Prime Volume Up Mascara Super Waterproof
The premium version with added lash care ingredients. Similar performance to the Volume and Curl but with a slightly refined formula. Also available: Heroine Make Prime Long Up Mascara Super Waterproof for length.
How to choose between them: If you want volume, go Volume and Curl. If you want length, go Long and Curl Super WP. If you want the latest formula with lash care, go Prime. They all hold curl equally well and they’re all equally hard to remove.
Best for Short and Sparse Lashes: Heroine Make Long and Curl
For people with very short or sparse lashes, the priority is finding a mascara that grips individual lashes and extends them without weighing them down. Heavy, volumizing formulas tend to make short lashes droop.
Heroine Make Long & Curl Mascara Advanced Film is the best starting point here. The slim wand catches short lashes that wider brushes miss, and the film formula is lighter than the waterproof versions.
The Heroine Make Mini Mascara takes this further with an even thinner wand specifically designed for hard to reach lashes. It works well as a standalone mascara for people who want a natural look, or as a precision tool for inner corner and lower lashes alongside a different mascara.
For a non Heroine Make alternative, the Kose Fasio Permanent Curl Mascara Waterproof Long has a curved wand that lifts lashes from the root while adding length. It’s a well regarded option in Japan that Teen Vogue highlighted, though it’s harder to find outside Japan (primarily available through YesStyle and similar importers).
Budget Pick: Canmake Metalook Mascara
Canmake regularly proves that effective mascara doesn’t need to cost more than lunch. The Metalook Mascara costs under $15 and routinely ranks in @cosme’s top mascara lists.
The standout feature is the thin metal comb wand. Unlike traditional bristle brushes, the metal tines separate each lash individually, which prevents clumping and gives a clean, defined result. This makes it particularly good for creating the “manga lash” look (clustered, separated lashes) without falsies.
What it does:
- Excellent separation with zero clumping
- Adds length and light volume
- Holds curl well
- Metal wand reaches fine, short lashes that bristle brushes miss
Canmake also offers the Canmake Metalook Mascara Volume Look for people who want more thickness from the same metal wand design.
Canmake
1 retailerSee retailers →
For an even cheaper option, the Cezanne Lasting Curl Mascara clocks in around $9 and is known for its double sided applicator that evenly coats and separates lashes. Many people use it as a mascara primer, applying it first for length before layering a different mascara on top. It’s a staple of @cosme’s drugstore rankings in Japan.
The Cult Classic: Dejavu Fiberwig
Dejavu Fiberwig is the mascara that put “film type” on the map. It was one of the first mascaras to popularize warm water removal, and it still has a dedicated following.
The formula coats lashes in tiny fiber tubes that add length. At the end of the day, warm water dissolves the tubes and they slide off cleanly. No smudging, no panda eyes, no oil cleanser needed.
The honest take: Fiberwig is great at what it does (clean removal, no smudging, decent length), but it has limitations. It doesn’t hold curl as well as Heroine Make’s film formulas. Multiple users in that same Reddit thread reported that Fiberwig let their curl drop within hours, while Heroine Make held all day. If curl hold is your priority, Heroine Make Advanced Film is the better film type option.
Where Fiberwig excels is comfort and removal. The formula is lighter on the lashes, and the removal process is almost effortless. For people who prioritize gentle treatment of their lashes or who find Heroine Make too intense, Fiberwig is a solid alternative.
Availability note: Dejavu Fiberwig can be harder to find outside Japan compared to Heroine Make products. Check specialty importers and online retailers that stock Japanese cosmetics.
Dejavu
0 retailersSee retailers →
Other Worth Knowing About
Opera My Lash Advanced Mascara
Opera (the same brand behind the popular Lip Tint Oil Rouge) makes a slim, precise mascara that creates a natural, elongated look. The application is thin and controlled, making it good for people who want subtle definition rather than drama. The downside is that it can smudge after several hours of wear, so it’s better suited for shorter outings than full day use. Not widely available outside Japan.
DHC Perfect Pro Double Protection Mascara
DHC Perfect Pro Double Protection Mascara
A tubing mascara from DHC with a flexible wand. It resists flaking and clumping during the day and washes off with warm water. The formula is lighter than Heroine Make, which some people prefer. Available in black and brown. Reportedly Emma Watson’s mascara of choice, for whatever that’s worth.
DHC
1 retailerSee retailers →
Majolica Majorca Lash Expander Long Long Long Mascara
A lengthening focused mascara from Shiseido’s Majolica Majorca line. The name is accurate: it adds significant length through fiber technology. It’s been a drugstore staple in Japan for years. Limited availability outside Japan, but worth picking up if you visit.
K-Palette 1 Day Lash Up Silky Long Mascara
A newer entry that’s been climbing @cosme rankings. K-Palette is known for eyeliners, but their mascara uses a smooth film formula that adds length without the dryness some film mascaras have. Worth watching if you see it.
How to Remove Japanese Mascara
This is the part most guides skip, and it’s arguably the most important. Using the wrong removal method will either leave you with raccoon eyes or damage your lashes.
Film type mascaras (Heroine Make Advanced Film, Dejavu Fiberwig, DHC)
- Wet your fingers with warm water (around 38 to 40°C, noticeably warm but not hot)
- Gently pinch your lashes between your wet fingers
- Slide downward. The tubes should come off in small, dark pieces
- Follow up with your regular cleanser
The key is temperature. Lukewarm water won’t work. The water needs to be warm enough to dissolve the polymer.
Waterproof mascaras (Heroine Make Super WP, Volume and Curl)
- Use an oil based cleanser, cleansing balm, or dedicated mascara remover
- Press a cotton pad soaked in remover against your closed eye for 10 to 15 seconds
- Gently wipe downward. Don’t rub
- Repeat if needed, then follow with your regular cleanser
The Heroine Make Speedy Mascara Remover is designed specifically for the brand’s waterproof line and works faster than most general cleansing oils. Many regular Heroine Make users consider it non negotiable.
Common mistake: Trying to remove waterproof Japanese mascara with micellar water or a gentle cleanser. It won’t work. You’ll end up rubbing your eyes and pulling out lashes. Use oil.
FAQ
Why is Japanese mascara so good at holding curl?
Japanese mascaras are formulated for straight, downward pointing lashes, which are common among East Asian populations. Holding a curl is the primary design goal, so brands invest heavily in polymer technology and wax systems that lock lashes in position. Western mascaras tend to prioritize volume and length, assuming lashes already have some natural curl.
What is film mascara?
Film mascara (also called tube mascara) coats each lash in a water soluble polymer tube rather than using traditional wax and pigment. The tube resists sweat and oil during the day but dissolves in warm water, making removal easy. The technology was popularized by Japanese brands like Dejavu and has since spread to Western brands too.
Can I use Japanese mascara if I have sensitive eyes?
Most film type Japanese mascaras are a good choice for sensitive eyes because they don’t require rubbing or harsh removers to take off. The warm water removal process is gentle. However, waterproof formulas require oil based removal, which may irritate some people. Check ingredient lists if you have specific allergies. Many Japanese mascaras are fragrance free.
Do I need a mascara primer with Japanese mascara?
Not necessarily. Heroine Make and most Japanese mascaras are designed to hold curl on their own. However, some people use the Cezanne Lasting Curl Mascara or a clear mascara base like the Pmel Perfect Curl Mascara Base to add extra length before applying their main mascara. If your lashes are very short, a primer can help by giving the mascara more surface area to grip.
How do I choose between so many Heroine Make mascaras?
Start with what you want to prioritize. For everyday use with easy removal: Long and Curl Advanced Film. For maximum waterproof hold with volume: Volume and Curl Mascara. For waterproof hold with length: Long and Curl Super WP. For a precision wand on short lashes: Mini Mascara. The Heroine Make Guide breaks down the full lineup in detail.